陈良斌（马克思主义学院）：承认理论的精神分析何以可能——论霍耐特与怀特布克之争
陈良斌：承认理论的精神分析何以可能：论霍耐特与怀特布克之争
陈良斌（马克思主义学院）在《东岳论坛》2026年第5期撰文，辨析承认理论的精神分析何以可能。文章围绕霍耐特与怀特布克的争论，以承认、融合、全能与共生等概念为线索，讨论主体间性、自主性及精神分析对承认理论的作用。
May． 2026 Vol．47 No．5 2026 5 47 / 5 Dong Yue Tribune
“ ” 20BKS185
。
1981— 、
。
① · Joel Whitebook 。1947 1977
Albrecht Wellmer · 、 · Hans Jonas 。
、 、 。
。
② 《 ——— 〈 〉》 《 》 2021
1 。
210089
、
。
。 。
。
。
、
。
B516 A 1003－8353 2026 05－0138－09
、 、 、
。 ·
· ① 。
1995 《
》 。 2014 ②。
2021 。
。
。 “ ”
。
、
。
831
DOI:10.15981/j.cnki.dongyueluncong.2026.05.012
、
“ ” recognition 。
。
、 、
。 ①
② 。
。 、
。 。
———
“ ” fusion 。
“ ”③ omnipotence 。
。 “
”④
、 。
⑤ symbiosis symbiotic fusion 。
。
。 。
。
。 。
“ ” “ ”。
“ ” “ ” “ ” primary fusion ⑥。
“ ” “ ”
。 “ ” the first not－me possession
。
。 “ ”
931
①
②
③
⑤
⑥
④ · 《 》 2005 72 77 。
· · 《 》 《
》 2007 267 。
“ ” all power 。
1 2
3 4 。 Elizabeth L． Auchin-
closs Eslee Samberg eds． Psychoanalytic Terms and Concepts New Haven Yale University Press 2012 p．183．
caregiver “ ” the biological mother 。
· 《 》 136 12。
William Ｒehg James Bohman eds． Pluralism and the Pragmatic Turn The Transformation of Critical Theory Cam-
bridge The MIT Press 2001 p．278．
“ ”①。
“ ”②。
“ ”
。“ 。”③
④。
“ ” primordial state of symbiosis ⑤
。
“ ” symbiosis 。 “ ” “
”⑥。 《 》 。
。
。
⑦ “ ” fusion self 。
“ ”。
⑧ “ ” 。
“ ” prelinguistic self “
” 。 、
。
。 。
。
。 。
merged ⑨。 “ ”
。
。 “ ” interaction “
” intersubjectivity 。 “ ”
⑩。
。 —
“ ” 。 “
。”11
。 “ ” “ ” sociability
。 “ ”
“ ”
041
May． 2026 Vol．47 No．5 2026 5 47 / 5 Dong Yue Tribune
①
④
⑤
⑥
⑦
②③⑨11Axel Honneth Joel Whitebook “Omnipotence or Fusion A Conversation Between Axel Honneth and Joel White-
book” Constellations 2016 23 2 p．173 p．173 p．173 p．175 p．178．
⑧William Ｒehg James Bohman eds． Pluralism and the Pragmatic Turn The Transformation of Critical Theory p．278 p．
270．
⑩Axel Honneth “Postmodern Identity and Object－Ｒelations Theory On the Seeming Obsolescence of Psychoanalysis”
Philosophical Explorations 1999 2 3 p．233 p．236．
· 《 》 106 。
Inara Luisa Marin “Interview with Axel Honneth”2009－03－12 https / / www．journal－psychoanalysis．eu / articles / interview
－with－axel－honneth / ．
。
①。
“ ” 。
“ ” “ ”
。
“ ” “ ”
。 “ ” 。
。
②。 。
。
。
③。 。
Kleinians 。
manic defenses 。
、 、 。
“ ” 。
“ ”
antisocial tendencies ——— ④。
。
———
。
。
。
、
⑤。
。 “ ” “ ” “ ”
———
“ ” zerrissene 。 。
。
。
。
141
①
②
⑤
William Ｒehg James Bohman eds． Pluralism and the Pragmatic Turn The Transformation of Critical Theory p．279．
③④Axel Honneth Joel Whitebook “Omnipotence or Fusion A Conversation Between Axel Honneth and Joel Whitebook”
p．176 p．178 p．177．
《 》 2009 29—30 。
。
。
。
。 、 。
。
“
。”①
。
。
、 。 death drive
。
。
。 。
。 “
。”②
erotic drive “
。”③ “ ”
。
。
。
。
④。
。
。 “
”⑤。
。
。
。
⑥。
241
May． 2026 Vol．47 No．5 2026 5 47 / 5 Dong Yue Tribune
①
②
④
⑤
⑥
Joel Whitebook “Hans Loewald Psychoanalysis and the Project of Autonomy” Journal of the American Psychoanalytic As-
sociation 2008 56 4 p．1166．
③Inara Luisa Marin “Interview with Axel Honneth”2009－03－12 https / / www．journal－psychoanalysis．eu / articles / inter-
view－with－axel－honneth / ．
· 《 》 、 2021 226 。
· 《 》 112 。
Axel Honneth Joel Whitebook “Omnipotence or Fusion A Conversation Between Axel Honneth and Joel Whitebook”p．176．
。
comformism 。
。
。
“ ” naturalistic basis of aggression “ ”
。 “ ” 。
“ ”①。
。
。
“
” ②。
。 。
③。 。
。
。
、 。
④。
、 “ ”
———
“ ” 。
。
、
。
“ ” 。
。 “ ”
“ ”
⑤。 “ ” 、
。
moralistic idealism normative idealism ⑥。
、 。
。 。
341
①
③
⑥
②⑤ · 《 》 239 96 211 。
④Inara Luisa Marin “Interview with Axel Honneth”2009－03－12 https / / www．journal－psychoanalysis．eu / articles / inter-
view－with－axel－honneth / ．
Amy Allen Critique on the Couch Why Critical Theory Needs Psychoanalysis New York Columbia University Press 2020 p．27．
。“
。”① ·
②。
“
。”③ · “
。
。”④ 。
“ 、
。”⑤ 。
。
⑥。
meta－psychology
。
。 “ ” su-
per－ego “ ” ego ideal “
。
。”⑦
⑧。 。
。
。
。 。
———
、
、 。
。
、
。
——— 。
441
May． 2026 Vol．47 No．5 2026 5 47 / 5 Dong Yue Tribune
①
②
④
⑤
⑧
· 《 》 211—212 。
③Amy Allen Critique on the Couch Why Critical Theory Needs Psychoanalysis p．1 p．22 pp．23—24．
Jon Mills “Contemporary Psychoanalysis and Critical Theory A New Synthesis” Critical Horizons 2019 20 3 p．233．
⑥⑦Inara Luisa Marin “Interview with Axel Honneth”2009－03－12 https / / www．journal－psychoanalysis．eu / articles / in-
terview－with－axel－honneth / ．
Peter E．Gordon Espen Hammer Axel Honneth eds． The Ｒoutledge Companion to the Frankfurt School New York Ｒout-
ledge 2018 p．43．
。
。
、
。
。
。
。
①。
②。
。 “
”③。
。
。
。
。 、 ·
④。 ·
⑤。
· ·
。
⑥。
“ ”
。
⑦
。
。 “
”⑧。
“ ” 。
“
541
①
②
③
④
⑤
⑥
⑦
Axel Honneth Joel Whitebook “Omnipotence or Fusion A Conversation Between Axel Honneth and Joel Whitebook”p．171．
Amy Allen Critique on the Couch Why Critical Theory Needs Psychoanalysis p．27．
《 》 1 2009 544 。
Amy Allen “Ｒecognizing Domination Ｒecognition and Power in Honneth’s Critical Theory” Journal of Power 2010 3
1 pp．24—25．
Axel Honneth Danielle Petherbridge eds． Axel Honneth Critical Essays Leiden Brill 2011 pp．95—98．
· · 《 》 2009
157 。
⑧Lois McNay Against Ｒecognition Cambridge Polity Press 2008 p．24 p．40．
。”① 、
。 。
。
“ ” 。
———
②。
。
。 “
”③。 “
。 ……
”④。 “
”⑤。
。 。
。
。
。
。
。 、
。
“
。”⑥ 。
。
。 “
。
。”⑦
641
May． 2026 Vol．47 No．5 2026 5 47 / 5 Dong Yue Tribune
①
②
③
⑦
⑥ 《 》 1989 193 203 。
See Axel Honneth Judith Butler ＆ Ｒaymond Geuss Ｒeification A New Look at an Old Idea Oxford Oxford University
press 2008 p．110 Heikki Ikäheimo Kristina Lepold ＆ Titus Stahl eds． Ｒecognition and Ambivalence New York Columbia U-
niversity Press 2021 pp．147—151．
④⑤ · 《 》 2005 49
53—54 55 。
《 ——— — 》 《 》
2006 1 。
this basis an analytical framework of“infrastructure－social space－urban－rural integration”is constructed． Ur-
ban－rural integration is not only the outcome of institutional reform resource flows and population mobility but
also a process in which urban and rural social spaces are continuously restructured and reproduced through the
ongoing extension embedding and operation of infrastructure． Infrastructure functions through three dimen-
sions material institutional and relational． It improves transportation living facilities and information access
and promotes the overlap between urban and rural living worlds． By advancing the decentralization of digital
government affairs public service facilities and grassroots governance networks it facilitates the extension of
governance resources to the grassroots level． Through facilitating organizational mobility sustaining local pres-
ence and providing support it reshapes urban －rural social connections． Meanwhile infrastructure embodies a
duality of integration and differentiation． Accordingly urban －rural integration should not remain confined to
formal“connection” but advance toward a more equitable and inclusive reconstruction of social space．
How does the construction of the social credit system enhance China’s export technology complexity
—Empirical evidence from the national credit city pilot program
Lu Huizhi Zheng Wanteng Yin Tianbao 95
Strengthening the construction of the social credit system is not only an intrinsic requirement for improving the
credit system of the market economy but also a solid foundation for building the“dual circulation”development
pattern． It plays a critical strategic role in enhancing China’s export technology complexity． Based on panel da-
ta from 282 Chinese cities between 2011 and 2022 and using the national credit city pilot program as a quasi－
natural experiment this study employs a difference － in － differences DID model to evaluate the impact of
social credit system construction on export technology complexity． The results show that the construction of the
social credit system significantly promotes the complexity of city exports． Heterogeneity analysis reveals that this
effect is more pronounced in non－resource－based cities cities with higher administrative levels and cities with
better economic foundations． Mechanism analysis indicates that the construction of the social credit system en-
hances export technology complexity through attracting foreign investment accumulating human capital and en-
hancing market competition． Further analysis finds that there is a significant synergistic effect between the con-
struction of the social credit system and intellectual property protection policies jointly promoting the
improvement of export technology complexity． However the synergistic effects with digital infrastructure and
free trade zone policies are not yet significant．
How is a psychoanalysis of recognition theory possible
—On the debate between Honneth and Whitebook
Chen Liangbin 138
Focusing on the psychological motivations of inter －subjective recognition Axel Honneth and Joel Whitebook
have engaged in ongoing debates regarding the origins functions and methodologies of recognition． Ｒegarding
the origin of recognition Honneth adheres to the integration theory arguing that the primitive form of recogni-
tion demonstrates that the self possesses social characteristics from infancy onward． By contrast Whitebook
endorses the omnipotence theory maintaining that recognition results from the operation of omnipotence and is
shaped by an individual’s early monological psychological experiences． In terms of the functions of recogni-
tion Honneth advocates achieving social integration through the recognition desire while Whitebook believes
that the inherent negative tendency of humans is the driving force behind social order transformation． In terms
of the methodology of recognition Honneth believes that psychoanalytic methods only play an auxiliary role in
recognition theory whereas Whitebook seeks to promote psychoanalytic methods into the core of critical theory．
Overall the debate between them has effectively advanced the feasibility of integrating critical theory and
psychoanalysis． Nevertheless both sides overemphasize the psychological motives underlying the issue of recog-
nition reducing individual behaviors and social conflicts to external manifestations of the unconscious． Conse-
quently they fail to truly grasp the fundamental contradictions of capitalist society and unleash the emancipatory
potential of critical theory．
Clear governance in both capital and peripheral regions Political identity of the southern states under
the Western Zhou Dynasty’s governance
Zhao Yanjiao 166
The Western Zhou Dynasty’s governance of the southern regions was not aimed at alleviating the conflict
between population growth and resource shortages． Before the Spring and Autumn and Warring States periods
the central plains remained sparsely populated with no acute land－population tension． Moreover the Western
Zhou rulers consistently pursued a policy of pacification and assimilation toward ethnic minorities devoid of
genocidal warfare． The dynasty’s persistent governance of the south was solely to secure political recognition
from southern states maintain the functioning of the designated service system and ensure“hierarchical order”
so as to uphold “clear governance in both capital and peripheral regions．”
291
May． 2026 Vol．47 No．5 2026 5 47 / 5 Dong Yue Tribune
来源：马克思主义学院·科研成果 · marxism.seu.edu.cn